It is pretty striking that Stranger Things and Logan, within the space of a year and completely independently of one another, both gave us characters who are twelve year old girls that have been locked up, experimented on and used and abused for their unique abilities. Both girls are characterized by violent rage and scenes where they tear through entire groups of baddies who are after them, both are alienated from the outside world and from civilian behavior, and they even both have a shoplifting scene where they’re oblivious to customs of buying/selling and just walk into a store and take what they want, and turn violent when stopped by clerks. Both also have a sort of father issues narrative, and: both are somehow and at least at first presented as being silent.
There’s something very uneasy in thinking about the juxtaposition of all of this, but I do think Logan is more successful in not falling into traps of otherizing Laura and letting all this negatively affect her portrayal. This isn’t to pit Laura against Eleven, which might be rich of me to say given the title of this post, but it’s useful to examine harmful othering that unfortunately comes across with Eleven.